Jura Crêtes
Accueil OK     Plan de site     Imprimer Imprimer    
  Vous êtes ici : Revue de presse > Les dernières nouvelles en Europe
 
  ACTON PRINTEMPS EOLIEN
 
  >> REVUE DE PRESSE <<
  Presse suisse
  Presse française
  Presse allemande
  Ailleurs en Europe
  Reste du Monde
 
  Les projets
  Le concept national
  L'opposition
  Paroles de ...
  Efficacité énergétique
  Documents de référence
  Divers
  Protection des crêtes
  Paysage
 
  Fédération PRO-CRETES
 
  Association suisse PAYSAGE LIBRE
 
  Plateforme européenne contre l'éolien industriel - EPAW
 
  -->> Blogs :
  Voisine d'éoliennes
  Vent-de-Folie
  Vent-de-Folie's Photoblog
 
  INITIATIVE CANTONALE : AVENIR DES CRETES NEUCHATELOISES - SUCCES - 6400 SIGNATURES
 
  Eine kritische Auseinandersetzung mit Windenergie in der Schweiz
 
  Dessins de presse
 
  Non aux Quads !


Les dernières nouvelles en Europe


13.04.2002 - http://www.naboertilvindmoller.dk/

Seven Misconception About Wind Power - A Danish Appraisal

Notion 1: It saves fossil fuel

That is true, but don't ask how much. More than one thousand wind turbines in Holland help to save - what do you think? One thousandth part of the country's total domestic fuel consumption. If a new type of car was designed to save one thousandth of its fuel consumption, would that be called economical? Why should wind power be any different? [NB! these figures could be replaced by e.g. West European figures, or those of Denmark, but would lead to the same conclusions] 

Notion 2: It reduces the emission of greenhouse-gases.

This is also true, but again don't ask how much. This reduction is even less than the one thousandth given above, because part of our power generation is already free of greenhouse-gases: think of hydro-electric power and nuclear power. 

Notion 3: Wind power replaces electrical power stations.

This is incorrect. Each megawatt of wind power must be backed up by a megawatt of conventional power. For several weeks a year a wind farm generates no power, or too little power, because of insufficient wind. But the supply of current should preferably be continuous over this period. Or perhaps not? Should we welcome black-outs? Or California-type situations? And don't let them tell you that wind energy is "stored in the network" and can be used whenever you want it. It is not true.  

Notion 4: A half megawatt wind turbine provides electricity for a thousand families.

For a substantial part of the year the wind turbines are idling or generate too little power. During this period these families receive their electricity from the public network just like everyone else. By the way: who are these families? They always remain anonymous and cannot be checked.  

Notion 5: Large improvements in wind generation are yet to come.

Regrettably this is incorrect. A modern wind turbine draws *45% of the available energy from the wind. According to theory the maximum is 59%. Improvements by a factor of up to 1.3 are thus possible. This is no match for the disappointing 1/1000th savings, shown above. Moreover, such improvements would not remedy the unreliable generation of power caused by variable winds.  

Notion 6: Wind energy is still expensive but it will decrease in price.

Why should it?
Power from wind turbines is about 4 to 6 times more expensive than conventional power. The 1.3 times improvement that might be achieved will not help very much. Moreover, wind farms are moving from land or coastal sites to off-shore locations because of increasing environmental complaints. Off-shore wind farms are far more expensive and yield only slightly better at their improved locations. This will further increase the price of wind power. 

Notion 7: Denmark is an example for other countries.

This is true, but not in a good sense. Denmark generates more than 10% of its electricity consumption by wind: it is far ahead of other countries. 

a) But almost half of this power is instantly exported because it is generated at night or on weekends when the country is not able to consume it. Neighbouring countries import this current reluctantly, and at one fifth of the production cost. If these countries did not do that, the Danish network would be overloaded and black-outs would result.

b) At other times, when wind speeds are low, the Danish grid cannot satisfy the demand for electricity because too many conventional power stations have been pulled down in favour of wind farms. Electricity is then imported at a higher price from the same neighbouring countries that absorbed the Danish overload a few days earlier.

The truth is that the Danish network has become unstable because of its emphasis on wind power. It is only saved by its strong electrical links with the rest of Scandinavia and Germany. 

*[45% represents the maximum available at peak performance from the very largest wind turbines available.  AK]


Manifeste ENERGIE et PAYSAGE

Rassemblement suisse pour une politique raisonnable de l'énergie et de l'aménagement du territoire


Signez le MANIFESTE !

Revue de presse

Presse suisse
12.05.2012 - TRAMELAN - Un avenir énergétique durable pour le Jura bernois! C'est ainsi que les initiat...
En savoir +
11.05.2012 - VAUD - Les parcs éoliens de Valeyres-sous-Rances et de Bavois ont du plomb dans les pales....
En savoir +
09.05.2012 - VAUD - A l'heure où l'on souhaiterait entendre un canton parler de sa planification d'écon...
En savoir +
07.05.2012 - VAUD - La planification vaudoise en matière d’éolienne vise des objectifs ambitieux Le can...
En savoir +
02.05.2012 - LE NOIRMONT - Le vote des 239 ayants droit n'a pas fait l'ombre d'un pli. Décidément, les ...
En savoir +
02.05.2012 - NORD BROYE - Alpiq et la Romande Energie vont dresser un mât de mesure des vents, histoire...
En savoir +
02.05.2012 - TRAMELAN - Lundi, lors de la séance du Conseil général de Tramelan, le directeur des Servi...
En savoir +
01.05.2012 - THAL GAU OLTEN - Obmann-Stellvertreter Urs Allemann (Balsthal), seit zwei Jahren im Amt, h...
En savoir +
01.05.2012 - FRANCHES - MONTAGNES - La fronde anti-éoliennes s'étend dans le canton du Jura. C'est au t...
En savoir +
28.04.2012 - FMB - BKW INVESTISSEMENTS EN ITALIE - Les Forces motrices bernoises (FMB) ont acquis vendr...
En savoir +
27.04.2012 - SORTIE DU NUCLEAIRE - La stratégie du Conseil fédéral renforce la position des opposants a...
En savoir +
27.04.2012 - LE NOIRMONT - Les trois éoliennes du Peuchapatte auront-elles un jour des petites soeurs? ...
En savoir +
Presse française
16.05.2012 - FRANCE - La filière éolienne doit attendre un à deux ans une décision de la cour de justic...
En savoir +
27.04.2012 - PATRIMOINE MONDIAL - Dans les relations qui se tendent entre les porteurs de projets éolie...
En savoir +
23.04.2012 - FRANCE PAYS CATHARE - Tourisme et éoliennes ne font pas bon ménage... c’est en tout ca...
En savoir +
Ailleurs en Europe
28.04.2012 - FMB - BKW INVESTISSEMENTS EN ITALIE - Les Forces motrices bernoises (FMB) ont acquis vendr...
En savoir +
24.04.2012 - ARC ALPIN - Selon le Club Arc Alpin, le projet italien de construction d'un parc éolien su...
En savoir +
 
 
  © 2005 VTX Webpme. Tous droits réservés - Un produit VTX et Arcantel SA
Retour Homepage